Cross-Training – The History and Future of Transgender and Intersex Athletes (Page 8)

Summary

I believe that through this investigation I have demonstrated the following:

  • As human beings, intersex and transsexual athletes have every right to be included in athletic events.
  • Due to the rarity of their conditions, “separate but equal” competitions are highly impractical and discriminatory.
  • Current requirements for ensuring that hormonal advantages do not come into play are sufficient. In fact, these requirements may be highly unfair to younger athletes.
  • Sex-based differences in body morphology, where they occur, are often outweighed by the devastating impact of hormone replacement therapy on the body.
  • That cases where men have faked being women for sports competition are vanishingly rare.
  • That the possibility of creating “fake transsexuals” for unfair competition seems ludicrous.
  • Despite all fear and dread, transsexual and intersex athletes have never dominated any sport, and show no hints of doing such at this time, in any context.
  • That transsexual and intersex athletes have been consistently the subjects of abuse and discrimination for more than a century of organized sports.

In short, only an extremely small risk to fair sports competition is entailed by the welcome inclusion of transgender and intersex athletes.

References

Adair, Jessica L. “In a League of Their Own: The Case for Intersex Athletes” Sports Law. J. 18 (2011): 121-151.

Birrell, Susan and Cole, Cheryl L. “Double Fault: Renee Richards and the Construction and Naturalization of Difference” Sociology of Sport Journal 7 (1990): 1-21.

Boman, Steve and Callahan, Sean. “What Makes Supergran Run?” Salon.com 31 July, 2002. Online edition, accessed 3 January, 2014.

Borden, Sam. “Transgender Athlete Fails to Qualify” New York Times 21 June, 2012. Online edition, accessed 8 January, 2014. http://london2012.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/06/21/transgender-athlete-fails-to-qualify/?_r=0

Buzuvis, Erin E. “Transgender Student-Athletes and Sex-Segregated Sport: Developing Policies of Inclusion for Intercollegiate and Interscholastic Athletes” Seton Hall Journal of Sports and Entertainment Law 21.1 Article 1 (2011).

BVF – British Veterans Fencing committee meeting minutes, 15 Saturday, 2011, Angel Hotel, Chippenham, United Kingdom.

Cavanagh, Sheila L. and Sykes, Heather “Transsexual Bodies at the Olympics: The International Olympic Committee’s Policy on Transsexual Athletes at the 2004 Athens Summer Games” Body & Society 12.3 (2006): 75-112.

Devries, Michaela C. “Do Transitioned Athletes Compete at an Advantage or Disadvantage as compared with Physically Born Men and Women: A review of the Scientific Literature” Prepared for the Promising Practices: Working with Transitioning/Transitioned Athletes in Sport Project. May 18, 2008.

“Gabrielle Ludwig, first transgender basketball player to play college ball as both man and woman, keeps head high despite threats.” Associated Press, via The New York Daily News 14 December, 2012. Online edition, accessed 5 December, 2013.

Gorney, Cynthia “A 6-Minute Difference” Runner’s World 4 May, 2005. Accessed 30 June, 2013. http://www.runnersworld.com/runners-stories/6-minute-difference?page=

Griffen, Pat and Carroll, Helen J. On the Team: Equal Opportunity for Transgender Student Athletes October 4, 2010.

Hamilton, Mark “Elective Performance Enhancement Surgery for Athletes: Should it Be Resisted?” Acta Univ. Palacki. Olomuc., Gymn. 36.2 (2006): 39-46.

Heggie, Vanessa “Testing Sex and Gender in Sports; Reinventing, Reimagining and Reconstructing Histories” Endeavour 34.4 (December, 2010): 157–163.

Herscher, Laura “Gender Verification: A Term Whose Time has Come and Gone” Journal of Genetic Counseling 19.6 (2010): 551-553.

Hodgkinson, Will “’I don’t think about gender. I think about winning’” The Guardian 18 August, 2005. Online edition, accessed 4 December, 2013.

Hui et al. “Difference in Bone Mass Between Black and White American Children: Attributable to Body Build, Sex, Hormone Levels, or Bone Turnover?” Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism 88 (2): 642.

Hunt, Loretta “How Fallon Fox became the first known transgender athlete in MMA” Sports Illustrated – MMA & Boxing  7 March, 2012. Online edition, accessed 5 December, 2013.

Jomantas, Nicole “Kocab Returns for Epee Gold, O’Leary and Felty Win Saber Silver and Bronze at Veteran Worlds” USA Fencing 10 June, 2013.

Lucas-Carr, Cathryn B. and Krane, Vikki “What is the T in LGBT? Supporting Transgender Athletes Through Sport Psychology” The Sport Psychologist 25 (2011): 532-548.

Martínez-Patiño, María José “Personal Account: A Woman Tried and Tested” Lancet 366 (2005): S38.

Norlander, Matt. “Caster Semenya rightly chosen to bear South Africa’s flag at opening ceremony” CBS Sports 22 July, 2012. Online, accessed 22 November, 2013.

Opelka, Mike “50-Year-Old Transgender Basketball Player Joins Jr. College Women’s Team…Is This Fair?” The Blaze 15 December, 2013. Online edition, accessed 29 August, 2013.

Pilgrim, Jill et al. “Far from the Finish Line: Transsexualism and Athletic Competition” Fordham Intellectual Property, Media and Entertainment Law Journal 13.2 (2003): 495-549.

“Preserving la Difference” Time 16 September, 1966.

Randall, Joseph. “A Changing Game: The Inclusion of Transsexual Athletes in the Sports Industry” Pace I.P., Sports & Entertainment Law Forum 2.1 (Spring, 2012): 198-209.

Ritchie, Robert et al. “Intersex and the Olympic Games” J R Soc Med 101 (2008): 101: 395–399.

Serano, Julia. Whipping girl: A transsexual woman on sexism and the scapegoating of femininity. Seal Press, 2009.

Shy, Yael Lee Aura “‘Like Any Other Girl’: Male-to-Female Transsexuals and Professional Sports” Sports Law. J. 14 (2007): 95-110.

“Statement of the Stockholm consensus on sex reassignment in sports.” http://www.olympic.org/Documents/Reports/EN/en_report_905.pdf

Sullivan, Claire F. “Gender Verification and Gender Policies in Elite Sport: Eligibility and ‘’Fair Play’” Journal of Sport and Social Issues 35 (2011): 400-419.

Sykes, Heather “Transgender and Transsexual Policies in Sport” Women in Sport and Physical Activity Journal 15.1 (Spring, 2006): 3-13.

Travers, Ann “Queering Sport : Lesbian Softball Leagues and the Transgender Challenge” International Review for the Sociology of Sport 41 (2006): 431-446.

Wadler, Joyce “The Lady Regrets” New York Times 1 February, 2007. Online edition, accessed 2 January, 2014.

Wamsley, Kevin B. “Social Science Literature on Sport and Transitioning/Transitioned Athletes” Prepared for the Promising Practices: Working with Transitioning/Transitioned Athletes in Sport Project, University of Western Ontario, February, 2008.

Worsfold, David “Round Up – Vets News” The Sword (January, 2013): 37.

Zamoyta, Ruth. “Fair Play”. Unpublished essay, 2012.

Part 1 – Introduction and Early History
Part 2 – The Cruelest Test
Part 3 – Post-Richards to the Stockholm Consensus
Part 4 – Current Events
Part 5 – Let’s Get Physical
Part 6 – Why, oh Why, Must it be This Way?
Part 7 – Are There Any Cases Where an Advantage Seems Possible?
Part 8 – Final Summary and References (Current page)

Leave a Reply